Skip to content

Lower Plenty, 1987: The “First” Attack Most People Have Never Heard Of

Sam Hill
Lower Plenty, 1987: The “First” Attack Most People Have Never Heard Of
Natural bush land adjoins the Yarra River as it cuts through the valley in Lower Plenty.

If you want to understand the true profile of Mr Cruel, you have to look at how he officially introduced himself to the public.

According to the prevailing narrative, Mr Cruel's reign of terror began at 4am on Saturday 22 August 1987, in the suburb of Lower Plenty.

Lower Plenty is a quiet, bushy neighbourhood on the northern bank of Melbourne's Yarra River. Although located just 16 kilometres northeast of Melbourne’s central business district, it was home to 3,000 people at the time. Houses were built low and set among the trees on large acreage blocks, and with many still undeveloped, it afforded the perfect natural isolation for a predator who wished to move about unseen.

When you examine the mechanics of what the offender actually did inside the house he targeted that night, the idea that this was his first major outing in criminality is complete nonsense. This was not a man who committed a quick assault and fled into the night like an anxious, inexperienced amateur.

He stayed. For hours.

Melbourne was in the depths of winter, and on this particular night the city was being battered by a gale. Most of its three million residents were in bed, preoccupied with little more than the footy, with the final round of the home-and-away season being played that weekend. In Lower Plenty, the wind would have been tearing through the gum trees and snapping branches, creating exactly the kind of background noise a burglar would hope for.

At 4am, a couple in their thirties woke to find a masked man standing over them, armed with a handgun and a knife.

The intruder told the couple he was only interested in taking some personal belongings and having a shower. He asked where he could find a razor blade to shave with, a first aid kit and some clean clothes, giving the impression of a man who was down on his luck but otherwise relatively harmless. Whether they believed him was another matter. They were unarmed and still lying in bed, and they had no realistic option except to comply.

He forced them onto their stomachs and restrained their hands and feet with metal handcuffs. He then left the room, woke their six-year-old son and eleven-year-old daughter, and brought them both back into the master bedroom. The parents and their son were blindfolded and gagged with surgical tape, then herded into a wardrobe and locked inside.

Next, the intruder used the landline phone in the master bedroom to make a series of calls, and it seems he intended the family in the wardrobe to overhear them. They heard him call the person on the other end a "bozo", and warn someone to "move your children or else they'll be next."

It remains uncertain whether this was a genuine threat to a future target or a ruse to send investigators down a fabricated lead. Some reports suggest that when the phone records were eventually checked, there was no evidence of an outgoing call at all. At first, though, police treated it as genuine, and issued a public appeal for whoever had received the call to come forward.

No one did.

Once he had finished making, or staging, these calls, the intruder tuned the radio to AM frequency 3KZ, the most popular classic hits station of the era. He turned the volume up high to mask what was about to happen, and took the eleven-year-old girl out of the bedroom. He asked for her name and age, which she gave him. He then disregarded her answer entirely, insisting on calling her Kate, which was not her name.

Over the next two hours, the girl was assaulted repeatedly, in more than one room of the house. Between the assaults, the offender would rest, or move through the house collecting items to steal. At one point he went through the fridge, ate the family's leftover dinner and poured himself a glass of milk. Police cited this as evidence of his brazenness and composure, which is accurate, but it wasn't the unique signature they implied. Plenty of burglars do the same.

He also returned to the master bedroom several times, allegedly to check on the welfare of the parents and their son. I seriously doubt that was his intent. I suspect these checks were to confirm that nobody was close to escaping their restraints.

During one of these feigned "welfare checks", he re-bound the family's hands and feet with nylon cord, and removed the original six pairs of metal handcuffs.

For some reason, police became convinced that this nylon cord wasn't available in Australia. It was. And because they couldn't conceive of how anyone could obtain it without international connections, they sent themselves down a dead-end rabbit hole of international intrigue.

Before he left, the offender made the girl shower, brush her teeth and clean under her fingernails, presumably to eliminate any trace of saliva or skin that could genetically link him to the scene. That may sound routine now, but this was 1987. DNA analysis had not yet been used in a criminal trial anywhere in the world, and it was still two years from being used in Australia. Yet it seems this man was not only aware of the emerging science, but was already putting countermeasures in place.

That alarmed the police considerably, and the public theory that Mr Cruel was a police officer has remained a favourite for the next forty years. But science journalists had been reporting on DNA for some time. Perhaps the police didn't read the science sections of the newspaper. The crime journalists obviously didn't either, even when it was printed in their own paper.

The papers ran a surprising number of detailed articles on DNA and forensic science in the months before the Lower Plenty attack, some of them only days before.

📖
I've gone through the historical articles. Read about them in:
Behind the Chapter: Lower Plenty | What the Papers Knew.

There were other clues, too.

The offender washed the dishes after his meal, which may have been about his saliva, but he also returned the milk carton to the fridge, which serves no risk management purpose. And at some point he also cleaned up the broken glass of the window he'd smashed to gain entry. This could be a measure to ensure none of his fingerprints were inadvertently left behind, but it makes no sense given he wore gloves throughout. It seems he simply couldn't stand looking at the mess.

These appear to be obsessive-compulsive traits sitting alongside genuine forensic awareness. But for some reason the police largely withheld them from the public, even though they are exactly the kind of observable traits that would have made him identifiable to family and friends.

Once the offender had finally finished assaulting and eating and cleaning, he left his victim in a lounge chair. He told her he was leaving, and that she was to count to one hundred before removing her blindfold and going to untie her parents, who were still confined in the bedroom.

And with that, he left.

His haul comprised $250 in cash, a valuable and distinctive diamond ring, a vinyl record set titled Classic Gold by the London Philharmonic Orchestra, which police wrongly claimed was rare, and a man's blue winter coat, a boutique South American brand that was very likely the only one of its kind in Australia. Apart from the coat, which he probably wore as he left, everything would have fitted into the small grey fabric bag he had brought with him, which police said looked somewhat like a child's school library bag.

By the time the girl had managed to untie her parents, the offender was long gone. Nor could they call the police immediately, because he had kindly cut their phone line.

Neighbours later reported a prowler in the area in the weeks before the attack, associated with a dark blue sedan.

Despite the heinous nature of the crime, the case attracted little public attention. The girl hadn't been killed, and she wasn't missing, so the media were given no personal information about the family. With no house to stand in front of, no photographs to publish and no quotes from relatives, it simply wasn't a compelling story.

That would change the following year.


The Lower Plenty attack was not an isolated event, and the police knew it.

Concerned that the offender would strike again, they held a press conference the following week and disclosed that Lower Plenty was only the latest in a series of similar unsolved burglaries and rapes in the area over the preceding two years.

A pinboard showcasing the police sketches of the offender and his weapons was displayed at the press conference. Image courtesy of Channel 9, Under Investigation.

The local cluster began in December 1985, with three similar attacks over four days. On 4 December in Warrandyte, a thirty-year-old woman was confronted by an armed offender wearing a balaclava, gloves and fawn overalls, who emerged without warning from a walk-in closet in her bedroom.

Two days later in neighbouring Donvale, he broke in while the occupants were out. When a thirty-year-old resident and her seventeen-year-old sister returned, he tied the younger sister with pantyhose and locked her in a closet. He then restrained the older sister with the exact same type of nylon cord later used at Lower Plenty, and sexually assaulted her over a ninety-minute period. He periodically checked on the sister in the closet, and before leaving, he ripped the landline phone from the wall. Police described it as a "virtual blueprint" of Lower Plenty.

The following night, in Bulleen, a thirty-four-year-old woman was confronted by an armed intruder and sexually assaulted while her six-year-old daughter was home.

Police also referred to two more recent attacks in Greensborough, one in March 1987 and another only two weeks before the Lower Plenty attack. Both times the offender struck while the victims were asleep, and police believed he had been surveilling the occupants beforehand.

Those familiar with Melbourne will recognise how tightly these five suburbs are clustered. Greater Melbourne had over 200 suburbs at the time, and yet every one of these attacks happened within two or three suburbs of Lower Plenty.

The sprawl of Greater Melbourne around Port Phillip Bay. The locations of the precursor attacks in the north east are shaded in blue. Lower Plenty is shaded purple. The tight clustering of attack locations in the north east is clearly visible.

The choice of these neighbourhoods was no coincidence, and I'll come back to what they had in common. Because the next family he tormented lived in a neighbourhood with many of the same features.